Tuesday, February 22, 2005

AMERICAN IDOL THOUGHTS

LONG-WEEKEND LINKS
 

OK, I had myself a nice three-day weekend. I headed out of town and really tried to stay away from the computer for as long as possible! Of course, I had to try to do my taxes in there too, but I guess that has to be done!

Today also starts my American Idol Thoughts. Those of you who have been reading this site for over a year know that I enjoy American Idol. I believe that it should be required viewing for schools, at least through middle school. I think it shows that music and singing can be considered cool! Anyway, what I will do is write a few brief thoughts about how I thought each singer performed and then quickly rank how I think they did, therefore showing the two that I think should be eliminated. I hope you enjoy this feature as I will be doing this each time there are performances. Last night, the 12 boys/men sang and America will vote out two of them on Wednesday. Tonight, 12 girls/women will sing and two of them will also be eliminated based on America's vote, on Wednesday.

Anyway, I did work on a couple of projects over the weekend that will help me with future projects. However, for today, I am just going to provide you with a number of links and other thoughts that have been running through my head. OK, I am not going to bore you with all of the messed-up thoughts running through my head. I will confine it to, well, anything else.

But if, by chance, you have missed any of the divisional fantasy perspectives, check them out here. Tomorrow, I will be posting the National League East hitters.

Part 1 - American League Central Hitters
Part 2 - American League East Hitters
Part 3 - American League West Hitters
Part 4 - National League Central Hitters
Part 5 - National League East Hitters

Again, if you have any questions or comments on anything, please e-mail me.

TUESDAY LINKS

Here are just a few other sites that I noticed over the past few days:

AMERICAN IDOL THOUGHTS

It is now Season 4 of American Idol. So far, winners Kelly Clarkson, Ruben Studdard and Fantassia Barrino have all been very successful. But so have Clay Aiken, Josh Gracin, Diana Degarmo and other contestants. Like Independent sports leagues, I love the concept of this show; giving people who wouldn't otherwise a chance to make it big.

There are a number of changes this year in the format of the show. Many were seen in previous weeks. The main one this year is that there will be six mean and six women in the final competition. Right now, there are 12 men and 12 women still in the competition. Last night, the 12 men each sang one song. America was asked to vote for their favorite. Tonight, 12 women will each sing one song. America will again vote for their favorite. On Wednesday, the two men and the two women who receive the fewest votes will be eliminated from the show. This will happen the next two weeks again to get down to the final 12.

Anyway, as I have in the past, I will critique each of the contestants. What I do is watch the show with a little notepad and jot down a couple of thoughts as I hear them sing. I will post those brief thoughts, and then I will conclude by ranking the performances. Obviously this is strictly one person's opinion, mine, and not everyone needs to agree with me. You will find that in some cases, I completely agree with the judges. You will also note that there are a few occasions when I completely disagree with them.  So, let's get to it, but if you have any questions or comments, please be sure to e-mail me.

Nikko Smith - Part-Time Lover

Very strong voice. He sang high and low very well. To me, he sounded as good as Stevie Wonder did when he originally recorded it.

Scott Savol - You Are My Lady

Absolutely incredible vocally, as good as the original. He just looks and dresses really bad.

Anthony Federov - Hold on to the Night

He does have a strong voice in some ranges. But there are a number of weak spots, where he misses notes. He was a great story though (being told as a child that he may never even talk)

Bo Bice - Drift Away

He was far better when he was able to rock out on the chorus. It just didn't work for me when he was signing the verses.

Travis Tucker - My Shari Amor

Slow start, but once he started moving around, his voice got better, more in tune and stronger. Should have ended it before the "la-la-la's" though.

Constantine Maroulis - Kiss from the Rose

Horrible start on the verse, missed higher notes by far. But even his rocking was not good! Strange rendition of a great Seal song.

David Brown - Never Can Say Good Bye

He started out awful, just way out of tune, too low. Horrible song choice. From previous shows, he may have the most talent, but it didn't show last night!

Jared Yates - How Could I?

Excellent whiny voice, needed to clear his throat a little at times, but overall very good.

Anwar Robinson - Moon River

Looked confused, but really strong when he sang louder, just struggled with the low notes.

Judd Harris - Travelin' Band

At least he was fun and different. Certainly had a lot of charisma. He just looked like he was having fun. And, aside from all that, I thought he sang very well too.

Joseph Murena - How Am I Supposed to Live Without You?

The Kevin Millar/Barry Zito combo looking guy  had an excellent voice. Hit both slow and fast notes. And at the end, he even said "thank you"!

Mario Vazquez - What Do I Do?

Excellent falsetto and energetic.

SethSpeaks Rankings

I will rank the performers from #1 (best) to #12 (worst). In doing that, I would be saying that my choices for who should be eliminated would be numbers 11 and 12.

1.) Nikko Smith - Simon said his performance would be forgotten after five or six more performances. I thought it was the best!

2.) Mario Vazquez -

3.) Scott Savol -

4.) Judd Harris

5.) Joseph Murena

6.) Anwar Robinson

7.) Jared Yates

8.) Anthony Federov

9.) Bo Bice

10.) David Brown

11.) Travis Tucker

12.) Constantine Maroulis - it was just that bad!

 So, by that, I would have to guess that Travis Tucker and Constantine Maroulis will be the first two men eliminated. Check back tomorrow when I will analyze tonight's performances by the women. Again, if you have any thoughts, please e-mail me.

 

 

And on that note, I wish you a good day!. If you have any questions or comments on anything you have read above, please e-mail me.

 

Back to Archives           Home